Washington state courts publish public health emergency bench book

A number of jurisdictions have published bench guides for dealing with public health emergencies. The most recent of which I am aware comes from the courts in the state of Washington. Their Public Health Emergency Bench Book (HTML) (PDF) is a tidy little guide that provides a good checklist for any other court system considering what procedures are available during a public health emergency, as well as the practical considerations involved in providing justice when court personnel are missing or when sanitary conditions cannot be assured. Other bench books have been produced for the Indiana courts (updated July 2006) and Kentucky courts. Other jurisdictions have also prepared materials on courthouse preparedness (Google search).

NY Times article on the pervasive -- and perverse -- presence of IRBs on campus

Today's article is more about nonmedical research that is subject to IRB review and occasional veto, but it is interesting as a cultural marker that shows the spreading influence of the medical model of consent (and the growing pushback thereto).

Second Champaign hospital loses its exempt status

Health Business Policy has a news flash that the Champaign County (IL) "Board of Review reports that the Illinois Department of Revenue (“DOR”) has revoked the property tax exemption of a second hospital in Champaign-Urbana, the Carle Foundation Hospital in Champaign, Illinois, agreeing with the original recommendation filed by the Board of Review to the Illinois DOR in the spring of 2005." There's nothing on the DOR web site about the alleged affirmance.

The Board of Review's letter brief argued that the hospital was guilty of inurement by providing a practice platform for the for-profit physician group that operated it. Granted, this is the position of a single taxing authority (and maybe the state as well), but if that analysis is adopted widely, a lot of multi-specialty physician groups (at least the ones that aren't organized as nonprofits) with an affiliated health or hospital group are going to want to take a close look at whether they are organized and operated for a charitable purpose. Every entity's facts will be a little different, and exempt status is a "facts and circumstances" determination, but counsel for any such organization will want to pay close attention to the County's analysis of the inurement issue, as well as the other facts relied on in their brief.

Everything you always wanted to know about nanotechnology but were afraid to ask

Health lawyer Alan Goldberg alerted me to these nanotech-related publications from EPA:

• EPA's Science Policy Council's Feb. 15 white paper (pdf);
• EPA fact sheet
• EPA's nanotech web page

If you're coming to the nanotech party a little late, a good place to start would be the federal government's National Nanotechnology Initiative:

The National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI) is a federal R&D program established to coordinate the multiagency efforts in nanoscale science, engineering, and technology.

The goals of the NNI are to:

• Maintain a world-class research and development program aimed at realizing the full potential of nanotechnology;
• Facilitate transfer of new technologies into products for economic growth, jobs, and other public benefit;
• Develop educational resources, a skilled workforce, and the supporting infrastructure and tools to advance nanotechnology; and,
• Support responsible development of nanotechnology

Twenty-five federal agencies participate in the Initiative, 13 of which have an R&D budget for nanotechnology. Other Federal organizations contribute with studies,
applications of the results from those agencies performing R&D, and other collaborations. (See NNI Participants and NNI Structure and Strategies)

Lethal injection: what does the physicians' non-role portend?

Sunday's NY Times Magazine had an article by Elizabeth Weil on the boomlet of public and official opinion that is starting to cohere against the administration of the death penalty, in states that still have it, by lethal injection. Two articles in the past year by Atul Gawande (one in the New England Journal of Medicine and one in Nature) focus specifically on the role of physicians in such killings and are particularly worth reading.

AHLA's Health Lawyers Weekly (Feb. 9)

From the 9 February issue of AHLA's Health Lawyers Weekly:

Top Stories

• President Bush Issues FY 2008 Budget, Calls For Substantial Medicare, Medicaid Reductions
  President Bush issued his fiscal year (FY) 2008 budget proposal this week, calling for roughly $101 billion in savings from Medicare and Medicaid over five years. Full Story
• CMS Reports More Medicare Part D Beneficiaries Using Generic Drugs
  New data indicates that many Americans are saving money by switching to generic drugs, according to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). Full Story

Articles & Analyses

• Michigan Legislature Passes Provisional Nurse Licensure Statute, by Gregory W. Moore, Hall Render, Killian Heath and Lyman

Current Topics

• Arbitration/Mediation
  Ohio Appeals Court Upholds Nursing Home Arbitration Agreement Finding Procedural But Not Substantive Unconscionability
• Business Transactions
  Seventh Circuit Holds Management Company Breached Lease Agreement When Intermediary Care Facility Lost State CON
• ERISA
  U.S. Court In Michigan Finds Plan Member Has Standing To Sue Under ERISA Even Without Proof Of Personal Injury
• Food and Drug Law
  Drug Safety Legislation Introduced In Senate
• Fraud and Abuse
  1. Update
  2. U.S. Court In Arkansas Dismisses FCA Qui Tam Action Against Hospital And Rehabilitation Services Provider On Finding Of Insufficient Evidence
• Health Policy
  Major Employers, Union Team Up To Improve Healthcare System
• Healthcare Access
  Workers' Decision To Participate In Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance Plans Affected By Affordability Of Premiums, Study Finds
• HIPAA
  U.S. Court In Connecticut Says HIPAA Does Not Bar Ex Parte Interviews With Employees At Group Home Where Plaintiff Was Allegedly Neglected
• Hospitals and Health Systems
  1. Texas Appeals Court Finds Hospital District Waived Its Immunity By Filing Counterclaim To Physicians' Retaliatory Discharge Claims
  2. Lawmakers Question CMS About Specialty Hospital Following Patient Death In Texas
• Insurance
  U.S. Court In Texas Dismisses Hospital's Claims Against Plan Administrator After Plan Refused To Pay Because Of Pre-Existing Condition Exclusion
• Medicaid
  Study Finds Six States Have Reported Enrollment Drop Since Implementing New Medicaid Documentation Requirements
• Medicare
  1. OIG Presents Baseline Data On Medicare Part B Services For Nursing Home Residents
  2. U.S. Court In Tennessee Rejects MSP Action By Individual Claiming Standing As Qui Tam Relator
• News in Brief
  Low Health Literacy May Lead To Unsafe Care, Joint Commission Says
• Physicians
  Ninth Circuit Allows Physician To Proceed With Retaliatory Termination, Unfair Competition Claims Against IPA
• Quality of Care
  1. Most Patients Do Not Comparison Shop For Healthcare Services, Study Finds
  2. Public Reporting Efforts Help Improve Quality Of Care But Implementation Obstacles Remain, Report Says
• Tax
  IRS Issues Governance Guidelines For Charitable Organizations

(c) 2007, reprinted with permission of AHLA

Texas' HPV vaccination mandate: upon further reflection . . . .

The Saturday Times printed some interesting reactions to that paper's editorial support for the executive order by Texas Gov. Rick ("The Haircut") Perry that requires girls to receive HPV vaccinations before they would be allowed to enter sixth grade:

• Although you note the “opt out” approach taken by Gov. Rick Perry of Texas in which vaccination is required but parents can seek an exemption for reasons of conscience or religious beliefs, recommending the vaccine rather than requiring it could prove to be just as effective without violating the parents’ right to decide affirmatively — at least until the long-term effects are known. Amanda Styron
• Schools may rightfully require that children undergo immunizations that will protect schoolwide populations from acquiring communicable diseases, but cervical cancer does not fall into this category. However benevolent the intent, this is not a matter for Big Brother. Alan Katz
• In Texas, underscreening in African-American and Hispanic women probably accounts for their disproportionately high rates of cervical cancer. These adult women need access and coverage for screening. Unfortunately, there is no lobby for the Pap smear. Deborah Kamali, M.D.
• Compulsory vaccination has a legitimate place in our health care system. But why should the government restrict its vaccinations to the victims? Why not include the carriers? Sue Abercrombie
• Texas will pay hundreds of dollars per girl for the vaccination. Why not spend the money on health care, education about teenagers’ bodies and rights, enriching music, dance, art and science programs that engage, increase confidence and provide an alternative to sexual activity? What kind of people supply schoolgirls to a pharmaceutical company, allowing it to earn millions a year on such mandates? Elizabeth Beiter

Hospice - rethought and revised

There's a nice article in today's NY Times about hospice care and the ways in which it's being reimagined and revised to encourage its use by more patients and at an earlier stage in their illness. The key change is the option of continuing curative treatments while enrolled in hospice, which (i) makes hospice available to those who aren't ready to give up such treatments and (ii) reduces the incentive for such patients to opt for expensive hospital care -- often in the ICU -- at the end of life.